Why Dieting Doesn’t Usually Work by Sandra Aamodt (Video)
Set Point
Your brain has a “set point,” which is the weight range it believes you should weigh. The body’s regulatory system operates similarly to a thermostat, adjusting hunger, activity, and metabolism to maintain stability as your weight fluctuates. If you lose a significant amount of weight, your brain reacts as if you're in a famine, increasing hunger and reducing energy expenditure to push your body back to its perceived set point. Resistance to weight loss is an evolutionary response aimed at survival.
Eating Styles
Individuals fall into two main categories: intuitive eaters and controlled eaters. Intuitive eaters rely on their body's signals, eating when hungry and stopping when full. They spend less time thinking about food and are less likely to be overweight. On the other hand, controlled eaters attempt to manage their eating through willpower, often leading to overeating in response to external cues like advertising or buffet availability.
Healthy Habits
Research indicates that adopting healthy lifestyle habits such as eating fruits and vegetables, regular exercise, not smoking, and moderate drinking can significantly reduce the risk of death, regardless of weight. These habits promote overall well-being and longevity, highlighting the importance of focusing on health rather than weight.
Outcome of Dieting
Despite the common belief in dieting for weight loss, the typical outcome is often weight regain, with many individuals ultimately gaining more weight than they initially lost. This cycle of dieting and weight regain can have detrimental effects on both physical and mental health, contributing to disordered eating patterns and negatively impacting overall well-being.
Mindful Eating
An alternative approach to dieting is mindful eating, which involves listening to your body's signals, eating when hungry, and stopping when full. By paying attention to how your body feels during meals and respecting its hunger and satiety cues, you can develop a healthier relationship with food and reduce the likelihood of overeating or emotional eating.
Effects of Weight Obsession
Weight obsession can lead to eating disorders and other negative psychological outcomes, particularly among young individuals. Focusing excessively on weight and dieting can contribute to low self-esteem, body dissatisfaction, and unhealthy behaviors, emphasizing the need for a shift towards body positivity and self-acceptance.